Poll
Question: Go use the other topic
http://www.flipline.com/forum/index.php?topic=23686.0
http://www.flipline.com/forum/index.php?topic=23686.0

Pages: 1 ... 170 171 [172] 173 174 ... 263   
Print
Author Topic: Bidding Poll Topic  (Read 631511 times)
LogicallyLogical
FANDOM
Restaurant Master
*


You don't love me the same


View Profile
« Reply #2565 on: October 05, 2015, 01:23:02 PM »

Fair enough
Although we have used the Priest before
Logged

I believe but not in you and me...
The Real Alien
Guest
« Reply #2566 on: October 05, 2015, 01:24:42 PM »

wow I got less than have of these bids Sad y u hate me
anywaois
cons time

Beach Party: Replace Fool with Maniac/Vigi (preferably vigi) and its pretty good

Lupus’ Fate: again, replace the fool with Maniac

The Musical: Renamed roles again, Y NO DISGUISED WOLF AND MASON, a Veteran with infinite alerts, a Witch on the humans side, I have more chances of winning the lottery than winning as a Village Hermit

Transported to TV: WHAT ARE THOOOOOOOOOOooooooooose?: Pretty much half of it is messed up ex: black color roles make no sense and wtf is Barney?

Olden Days: I told the creator to replace the Refugee with a Vigilante, but they didn't (but we can fix this later) also disguised wolf and mason are not there

Reversed and Rewinded: Too much confusion

Chapel of God: That's a boring role list (not counting the fact that its offensive towards religious people)

Reverted: How does the Revertor win? Also Priest isn't a good role

I voted for Beach Party
Logged
noname
Guest
« Reply #2567 on: October 05, 2015, 01:28:37 PM »

> Barney
Logged
Kowhai
she/her
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #2568 on: October 05, 2015, 01:40:59 PM »

Chapel of God is too offensive of Christians like myself. I really do not like it.
I thought it was more offensive to Atheists like myself, with Atheism being depicted as a cult.

None of these are especially good except Olden Days and Reverted.

Beach Party - Surfer is next-to-useless, it's like a Miller who doesn't know the other Millers from the beginning. Every three nights is a big interval, and considering the length of your average TWG, he'll probably only hear about one or two people.

Lupus's Fate - Actually, this one's alright. I guess the main reason I don't like it is because the two new roles are so obviously based of ToS. But aside from that, it's alright.

The Musical - So many problems with this. I hate people renaming every role in a game to follow a theme, and the new roles are either so obviously based of ToS or just bad. Janitor is a Veteran with infinite alerts, Singer is Escort, Usher is Vigilante (ToS) with just one kill and School Nurse is Doctor (ToS) who can't heal on even nights. Even Extra is a Werewolf (ToS) who only kills their target. And the Script Writer, oh the SCRIPT WRITER. Like the Painter, it's a role which does more harm than good and would probably be better off with the wolves. Also, the Village Hermit is just too hard to win as. Just too hard. It's like the Pyromancer or whatever it was called from The Vampire Game 0 (and believe me, I speak from experience. It's not easy). Oh yeah, and Extra needs a way to win.

Transported to TV - No. Just no. Barney is a terrible idea. How do you hypnotise someone into thinking they're a wolf? If you mean just convert them into a wolf, then you should probably explain that more clearly. Also, his name, Barney. It's ridiculous, that's what it is.

Olden Days - I said this was one of the two good bids. There's just one problem in my opinion - It all seems a bit random. Aside from that, it's a good bid.

Reversed and Rewinded - Er, Rewinder's ability isn't very useful. How do you rewind a night or day? And what's the point of the people with abilities using their abilities the exact same way as before? If you just want it to be Night when it's Day, maybe, but you don't need to specify an exact Night/Day if that's the case.

Chapel of God - From what I can tell, both Atheists and Christians find this offensive. If there's one thing we don't need, it's an offensive TWG. So this idea is scrapped.

Reverted - Well, it's alright. Just a small problem: I don't see how converting them back to their base role helps an independent much, unless you just want to be a troll and piss them off. That's all I can say about it really.

Ranking:
1. Olden Days
2. Reverted
3. Lupus's Fate
4. Beach Part
5. Reversed and Rewinded
6. Transported to TV
7. The Musical
8. Chapel of God

Let me guess - You saw all the reviews, went 'tl;dr' and skipped down to the ranking. And possibly skipped the ranking.

EDIT: Actually, changed my mind. Lupus's Fate is now 2 and Reverted is now 3.
Logged

TWG stats:
TWGXI - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXII - Brutal Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXIII - Coroner (Victory)
TWGXIV - Guardian (Victory)

TWGXV - Hunter (Loss)
TWGXVI - Fool (Loss)

TWGXVII - Seer (Loss, Human MVP)
TWGXIX - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXXI - Human (Loss)
TWGXXII - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXIII - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXIV - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXXVI - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXXVII - Human (Victory)
TWGXXVIII - Disguised Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)

TWGXXX - Mason (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXXII - Mason (Victory)

TWGXXXIII - Trapper (Loss)
TWGXXXIV - Human > Cultist (Victory)
TWGXXXV - Cop (Loss)
TWGXXXVI - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXXVIII - Transporter (Victory)
TWGXXXIX - Mercenary (Unfinished)

TWGXL - Riddler (Loss)
TWGXLI - Amnesiac (Loss)
TWGXLII - Vigilante (Loss, Independent MVP)

TWGXLIII - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXLV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXLVI - Maniac (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXLVII - Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXLVIII - Moderator (Loss)
TWGL - Gentleman > Cultist (Loss)
TWGLI - Wrathful Tenant (Victory)
TWGLII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLIV - Bounty Hunter (Loss)
TWGLVI - Pack Leader (Victory)
TWGLVII - Amnesiac > Necromancer (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLVIII - Seer (Loss)

TWGLIX - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLX - Warden (Victory)
TWGLXI - Student (Loss)
TWGLXII - Student > Hunter (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLXIII - Human > Fool (Loss)
TWGLXV - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXVI - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLXVII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLXVIII - Wolf (Victory)

TWGLXIX - Traitor (Victory, HM)
TWGLXX - Amnesiac > Seer (Loss)
TWGLXXI - Tinker (Victory, HM)
TWGLXXII - Seer (Victory, Overall MVP)

TWGLXXIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLXXIV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXV - Mason (Loss)
TWGLXXVI - Wolf (Loss)

TWGLXXVII - Sun God (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXVIII - Soldier (Loss)
TWGLXXIX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXX - Insomniac (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXI - Vigilante (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXII - Human (Loss)
TWGLXXXIII - Psycho (Loss)

TWGLXXXIV - Potion Maker (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXV - Priest (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXVI - Insomniac (Victory)
TWGLXXXVII - Necromancer (Loss)
TWGLXXXVIII - Clairvoyant (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXIX - Succubus (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXC - Wolf Shaman (Victory, Wolf MVP)
TWGXCI - Brutal Wolf (Loss)
TWGXCIII - Eidetic Wolf (Loss)

TWGXCIV - Disguised Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXCV - Hypnotizer (Unfinished)
TWGXCVI - Amnesiac > Kingsley (Loss)
TWGXCVII - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXCVIII - Amnesiac > Wolf Shaman (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGXCIX - Tide Chimer (Victory)
TWGC - Clairvoyant (Loss)
TWGCIII - Necromancer (Victory)
TWGCIV - Knot Expert (Victory)
TWGCVI - Snezhinka (Loss)
TWGCXVIII - Mason (Victory)
TWGCXIX - Coroner (Victory, Overall MVP)

Hosted:
TWGXVIII: Traitor!
TWGXXV: The Inhospitable Hospital
TWGXXXI: Colourblind
TWGXXXVII: Cold Blood
TWGXLIV: Independence Day
TWGXLIX: Deserted
TWGLV: Video Games
TWGLXIV: A Ghost Story
TWGXCII: Werewolves in SPACE!
TWGCVII: Age of Mythology
The Real Alien
Guest
« Reply #2569 on: October 05, 2015, 01:51:01 PM »


Let me guess - You saw all the reviews, went 'tl;dr' and skipped down to the ranking. And possibly skipped the ranking.


I read it Smiley

anyway my ranking would be:
8. Chapel of God
7. The Musical
6. Reversed and Rewinded
5. Reverted
4. Transported to TV
3. Lupus’ Fate
2. Olden Days
1. Beach Party
« Last Edit: October 05, 2015, 02:21:49 PM by Lenny » Logged
Abu
Radley's Rival
*


ЦВЕТ НАСТРОЕНИЯ СИНИЙ


View Profile
« Reply #2570 on: October 05, 2015, 01:53:30 PM »

I only really like Beach Party and the Olden Days.
I think Chapel of God is offensive to Christian, Muslim, etc. but also Atheists since they are a cult...definitely not voting for it.
Logged
LogicallyLogical
FANDOM
Restaurant Master
*


You don't love me the same


View Profile
« Reply #2571 on: October 05, 2015, 01:54:16 PM »

Y u hate Chapel of God  Nervous

admittedly, the others I like are doing ok
Logged

I believe but not in you and me...
Abu
Radley's Rival
*


ЦВЕТ НАСТРОЕНИЯ СИНИЙ


View Profile
« Reply #2572 on: October 05, 2015, 01:55:05 PM »

Well 4 of us have reasons.

Offensive to religious and noneligious people.
Logged
LogicallyLogical
FANDOM
Restaurant Master
*


You don't love me the same


View Profile
« Reply #2573 on: October 05, 2015, 01:55:52 PM »

I'm not religious
And I don't find it offensive
I see how you would
Still  Nervous
Logged

I believe but not in you and me...
Kowhai
she/her
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #2574 on: October 05, 2015, 01:58:09 PM »

I'm not religious
And I don't find it offensive
I see how you would
Still  Nervous
Atheists being called a Cult. It's only non-offensive for people who just don't give a damn about religion.
Logged

TWG stats:
TWGXI - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXII - Brutal Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXIII - Coroner (Victory)
TWGXIV - Guardian (Victory)

TWGXV - Hunter (Loss)
TWGXVI - Fool (Loss)

TWGXVII - Seer (Loss, Human MVP)
TWGXIX - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXXI - Human (Loss)
TWGXXII - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXIII - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXIV - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXXVI - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXXVII - Human (Victory)
TWGXXVIII - Disguised Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)

TWGXXX - Mason (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXXII - Mason (Victory)

TWGXXXIII - Trapper (Loss)
TWGXXXIV - Human > Cultist (Victory)
TWGXXXV - Cop (Loss)
TWGXXXVI - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXXVIII - Transporter (Victory)
TWGXXXIX - Mercenary (Unfinished)

TWGXL - Riddler (Loss)
TWGXLI - Amnesiac (Loss)
TWGXLII - Vigilante (Loss, Independent MVP)

TWGXLIII - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXLV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXLVI - Maniac (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXLVII - Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXLVIII - Moderator (Loss)
TWGL - Gentleman > Cultist (Loss)
TWGLI - Wrathful Tenant (Victory)
TWGLII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLIV - Bounty Hunter (Loss)
TWGLVI - Pack Leader (Victory)
TWGLVII - Amnesiac > Necromancer (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLVIII - Seer (Loss)

TWGLIX - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLX - Warden (Victory)
TWGLXI - Student (Loss)
TWGLXII - Student > Hunter (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLXIII - Human > Fool (Loss)
TWGLXV - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXVI - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLXVII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLXVIII - Wolf (Victory)

TWGLXIX - Traitor (Victory, HM)
TWGLXX - Amnesiac > Seer (Loss)
TWGLXXI - Tinker (Victory, HM)
TWGLXXII - Seer (Victory, Overall MVP)

TWGLXXIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLXXIV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXV - Mason (Loss)
TWGLXXVI - Wolf (Loss)

TWGLXXVII - Sun God (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXVIII - Soldier (Loss)
TWGLXXIX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXX - Insomniac (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXI - Vigilante (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXII - Human (Loss)
TWGLXXXIII - Psycho (Loss)

TWGLXXXIV - Potion Maker (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXV - Priest (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXVI - Insomniac (Victory)
TWGLXXXVII - Necromancer (Loss)
TWGLXXXVIII - Clairvoyant (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXIX - Succubus (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXC - Wolf Shaman (Victory, Wolf MVP)
TWGXCI - Brutal Wolf (Loss)
TWGXCIII - Eidetic Wolf (Loss)

TWGXCIV - Disguised Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXCV - Hypnotizer (Unfinished)
TWGXCVI - Amnesiac > Kingsley (Loss)
TWGXCVII - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXCVIII - Amnesiac > Wolf Shaman (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGXCIX - Tide Chimer (Victory)
TWGC - Clairvoyant (Loss)
TWGCIII - Necromancer (Victory)
TWGCIV - Knot Expert (Victory)
TWGCVI - Snezhinka (Loss)
TWGCXVIII - Mason (Victory)
TWGCXIX - Coroner (Victory, Overall MVP)

Hosted:
TWGXVIII: Traitor!
TWGXXV: The Inhospitable Hospital
TWGXXXI: Colourblind
TWGXXXVII: Cold Blood
TWGXLIV: Independence Day
TWGXLIX: Deserted
TWGLV: Video Games
TWGLXIV: A Ghost Story
TWGXCII: Werewolves in SPACE!
TWGCVII: Age of Mythology
LogicallyLogical
FANDOM
Restaurant Master
*


You don't love me the same


View Profile
« Reply #2575 on: October 05, 2015, 01:59:13 PM »

Again I see how it would be OK
I say remove Chapel of God if people find it so offensive
Logged

I believe but not in you and me...
Abu
Radley's Rival
*


ЦВЕТ НАСТРОЕНИЯ СИНИЙ


View Profile
« Reply #2576 on: October 05, 2015, 01:59:35 PM »

And then the whole God thing for religious people too.
Logged
LogicallyLogical
FANDOM
Restaurant Master
*


You don't love me the same


View Profile
« Reply #2577 on: October 05, 2015, 02:00:21 PM »

I see how it would be
Logged

I believe but not in you and me...
Abu
Radley's Rival
*


ЦВЕТ НАСТРОЕНИЯ СИНИЙ


View Profile
« Reply #2578 on: October 05, 2015, 02:03:05 PM »

Oh okay.
Logged
Penguin022
Restaurant Pro
*



View Profile
« Reply #2579 on: October 05, 2015, 02:18:33 PM »

And there are too many ones with cult. Ever since Penguin's game with cult, the amount of cults have boomed up.
What can I say, I'm a trend setter? Tongue

@Lenny Lemme guess, you quote failed.

I actually wasn't offended by the Athiest Cult, I laughed out loud TBH. I totally didn't see it coming. If I were in a different mood, I'd probably have a different opinion on it, but Lenny's cons always make me happy. Laugh

IDK why everyone the TWC is revealing their rankings here, since it makes it pointless to rank them via PM. Oh well, I will do it as well.

Beach Party: I thought this was a pretty good game until Gundham pointed out Surfer isn't a great role. So there's that, and Fool should be Maniac. Or Assassin? But Warden being able to check themself on Night 3 onwards was a good idea.

Lupus's Fate: Maniac instead of Fool. Should be Lupus' Fate, not Lupus's Fate. Other than that, not bad.

The Musical: I don't have any problems with renaming roles to follow a theme (hint hint, I'm doing a theme in my next game) and I like musicals. Other than that this bid isn't good, Gundham and Lenny summed it all up. Check with me next time, and I can help you out with making a good bid that has to do with musicals~

Transported to TV: So much for a theme. Also, (sing this to the Barney theme) Barney was a dinosaur that was a terrible role. Of all TV, they chose Barney, a stupid freaking kids show.

Olden Days: Santa does not fit with this at all, should be Apprentice. And Traitor but no Detective? I don't like Hunter. And humans are OP. Plus, there is only 1 role that sorta-kinda has to do with the "olden days".

Reversed and Rewinded: Rewind to the previous reactions of Lenny and Gundham, sir/ma'am.

Chapel of God: No comment.

Reverted: Y U NO change things when I told you to change things. Humans are still a tad OP, by 1 role. I TOLD YOU SERIAL KILLER IS NAMED ASSASSIN *spams keys*. And I didn't even think of the fact that Revertor doesn't have a win condition.

1. Lupus's Fate
2. Beach Party
3. Olden Days
4. Reverted
5. The Musical
6. Reversed and Rewinded
7. Transported to TV
8. Chapel of God
Logged

Not removing my signature until Flipline makes a CMC3:
AskJoe [Jun 30 11:19 PM]:   Flipline should make Cactus McCoy 3.
Kangablue [Jul 02 12:59 AM]:   I want Cactus McCoy 3 now Sad
Phil Swift [Sep 12 07:43 PM]:   They need to make CMC 3
Penguin022 was quietly listening to his own music while also praying for Cactus McCoy 3 to come out, which honestly, would be a good idea since I love the game personally.
https://i.imgur.com/AdSe1IF.png
Pages: 1 ... 170 171 [172] 173 174 ... 263   
Print
Jump to:  













Sorry, you must have JavaScript enabled to use the Flipline Forum.