Poll
Question: Go use the other topic
http://www.flipline.com/forum/index.php?topic=23686.0
http://www.flipline.com/forum/index.php?topic=23686.0

Pages: 1 ... 215 216 [217] 218 219 ... 263   
Print
Author Topic: Bidding Poll Topic  (Read 632774 times)
Abu
Radley's Rival
*


ЦВЕТ НАСТРОЕНИЯ СИНИЙ


View Profile
« Reply #3240 on: February 04, 2017, 03:18:36 PM »

I kinda get it now
It's A LOT of things happening...and I voted no bc MIB is practically Captain's Daughter and..there are A LOT of things that'll go wrong with that.

The original Captain's Daughter or the newer version that only knows the Captain?
Logged
! !22-22-7
Franchise Owner
*****



View Profile
« Reply #3241 on: February 04, 2017, 03:26:55 PM »

To clear things up (as the bidder)
-Jacob is not a player in the game. Not one of the 17 players. He might as well be me. He's merely a condition that needs to be met before MiB can find and kill the Candidates
-MiB has no idea who the Candidates are, they could be any of the 16 players
-MiB has to kill 7 people, I believe that knowing the role list is fair
-can someone elaborate on "the worst seer results ever"?
-every phase, MiB can drug one player, who dies the next cycle (i.e. drugged Night 1 w/ no cure->dead Night 2)
-every phase, MiB can infect one player, rendering their skills useless (i.e. MiB infects Vinnie the Seer, Vinnie can't use seer)
-MiB can chose to either use one of the infected players' abilities, or control their lynch vote/wolf (useful, because MiB doesn't have any other method of killing)
« Last Edit: February 04, 2017, 03:32:49 PM by Vinnie927 » Logged
! !22-22-7
Franchise Owner
*****



View Profile
« Reply #3242 on: February 04, 2017, 03:33:20 PM »

I don't get it, I think the bidder should rework it to be more simple. There are too much things going on and some roles have a hard win rate.
How would you suggest doing that?
Logged
Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #3243 on: February 04, 2017, 03:36:00 PM »

'Worst seer results ever' include 4 Masons, 2 Disguised Wolves that both have powers, an entirely new colour (orange)

I kinda get it now
It's A LOT of things happening...and I voted no bc MIB is practically Captain's Daughter and..there are A LOT of things that'll go wrong with that.
It's not the Captain's Daughter though. It knows all of the roles, but it's an independent. It can maybe use this to fake being the Seer, or to know who to kill. It balances out the game.

The bidder's way of saying who Jacob is wasn't great. Pretend instead of 'Jacob', it's a button. The Guardian can protect the button from being pressed, other roles can press the button. When the button is pressed, a Candidate becomes the Protector and gains the ability to kill the Man in Black.

I agree, it's not a great bid, but you're making up problems.
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

! !22-22-7
Franchise Owner
*****



View Profile
« Reply #3244 on: February 04, 2017, 03:38:00 PM »

How would you change it?
-the overabundance of masons(millers)/disguised wolves gives more space for the MiB to hide
Logged
Oofis
Restaurant Legend
*


OOOOOOOOOOOOOO


View Profile
« Reply #3245 on: February 04, 2017, 03:39:36 PM »

-can someone elaborate on "the worst seer results ever"?
I can. The two humans who get seered red could pass as masons, and if someone is see red white, they're clearly the protector and therefore one of the candidates. Also, the addition of orange seer results just seems a bit weird to me, that's all. And sorry if I sounded a bit rude before, I didn't mean to be rude.
Logged

I don't know why I'm so obsessed with this marble racing bloop.

Btw add Oofis#8798 on discord if you wanna talk
noname
Guest
« Reply #3246 on: February 04, 2017, 03:50:54 PM »

Someone took Deathlock Castle as a challenge.
Logged
Kowhai
she/her
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #3247 on: February 04, 2017, 03:52:56 PM »

Behind the overly long description, it's a solid game, Vinnie can just alter the description to be less ridiculously long, it won't change anything about how the game functions.
Logged

TWG stats:
TWGXI - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXII - Brutal Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXIII - Coroner (Victory)
TWGXIV - Guardian (Victory)

TWGXV - Hunter (Loss)
TWGXVI - Fool (Loss)

TWGXVII - Seer (Loss, Human MVP)
TWGXIX - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXXI - Human (Loss)
TWGXXII - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXIII - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXIV - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXXVI - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXXVII - Human (Victory)
TWGXXVIII - Disguised Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)

TWGXXX - Mason (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXXII - Mason (Victory)

TWGXXXIII - Trapper (Loss)
TWGXXXIV - Human > Cultist (Victory)
TWGXXXV - Cop (Loss)
TWGXXXVI - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXXVIII - Transporter (Victory)
TWGXXXIX - Mercenary (Unfinished)

TWGXL - Riddler (Loss)
TWGXLI - Amnesiac (Loss)
TWGXLII - Vigilante (Loss, Independent MVP)

TWGXLIII - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXLV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXLVI - Maniac (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXLVII - Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXLVIII - Moderator (Loss)
TWGL - Gentleman > Cultist (Loss)
TWGLI - Wrathful Tenant (Victory)
TWGLII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLIV - Bounty Hunter (Loss)
TWGLVI - Pack Leader (Victory)
TWGLVII - Amnesiac > Necromancer (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLVIII - Seer (Loss)

TWGLIX - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLX - Warden (Victory)
TWGLXI - Student (Loss)
TWGLXII - Student > Hunter (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLXIII - Human > Fool (Loss)
TWGLXV - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXVI - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLXVII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLXVIII - Wolf (Victory)

TWGLXIX - Traitor (Victory, HM)
TWGLXX - Amnesiac > Seer (Loss)
TWGLXXI - Tinker (Victory, HM)
TWGLXXII - Seer (Victory, Overall MVP)

TWGLXXIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLXXIV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXV - Mason (Loss)
TWGLXXVI - Wolf (Loss)

TWGLXXVII - Sun God (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXVIII - Soldier (Loss)
TWGLXXIX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXX - Insomniac (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXI - Vigilante (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXII - Human (Loss)
TWGLXXXIII - Psycho (Loss)

TWGLXXXIV - Potion Maker (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXV - Priest (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXVI - Insomniac (Victory)
TWGLXXXVII - Necromancer (Loss)
TWGLXXXVIII - Clairvoyant (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXIX - Succubus (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXC - Wolf Shaman (Victory, Wolf MVP)
TWGXCI - Brutal Wolf (Loss)
TWGXCIII - Eidetic Wolf (Loss)

TWGXCIV - Disguised Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXCV - Hypnotizer (Unfinished)
TWGXCVI - Amnesiac > Kingsley (Loss)
TWGXCVII - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXCVIII - Amnesiac > Wolf Shaman (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGXCIX - Tide Chimer (Victory)
TWGC - Clairvoyant (Loss)
TWGCIII - Necromancer (Victory)
TWGCIV - Knot Expert (Victory)
TWGCVI - Snezhinka (Loss)
TWGCXVIII - Mason (Victory)
TWGCXIX - Coroner (Victory, Overall MVP)

Hosted:
TWGXVIII: Traitor!
TWGXXV: The Inhospitable Hospital
TWGXXXI: Colourblind
TWGXXXVII: Cold Blood
TWGXLIV: Independence Day
TWGXLIX: Deserted
TWGLV: Video Games
TWGLXIV: A Ghost Story
TWGXCII: Werewolves in SPACE!
TWGCVII: Age of Mythology
Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #3248 on: February 04, 2017, 03:54:56 PM »

I've rewritten the Man in Black's abilities to be a lot shorter and to the point.
Spoiler:
-Night immune to all except Protector
-Can change his colour every night, similar to Dauber Wolf
-Knows all Player's roles, and their actions each night (i.e Nickito guarded Lenny)
-Once each Day and Night, can throw a heroin bag at someone to 'poison' them. The next Day/Night, the 'poisoned' person will die if they are not healed by Jack or Juliet.
-Each Night can infect a player and steal their night power. Can use their power the same night, or steal  their lynch vote for the next day unless they are disinfected by Ethan or Desmond.
-His lynch votes do not count.
-Wins when Jacob and all 6 Candidates are dead. Overrides Human/Wolf victory.
-The Candidates are 6 random players that can be Human or Wolf. They know that they are candidates, the MIB does not.
-Once Jacob is killed by the Man in Black, he learns the Candidate's names and a random Candidate becomes the Protector
-The Protector is seer'd white and in addition to their normal night power, can also choose to attack someone.
-If they are the MIB, they die. If not, nothing happens.
-The Protector's role does not change otherwise.
-Jacob isn't a role in the game, he is an abstract concept.
-Players can use powers on Jacob like they normally would to anyone else
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #3249 on: February 04, 2017, 03:58:45 PM »

Changes I would make:
-Protector no longer becomes White
-Jacob is not a thing anymore, Man in Black learns about the Candidates' identities after one dies from his actions
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

! !22-22-7
Franchise Owner
*****



View Profile
« Reply #3250 on: February 04, 2017, 04:10:58 PM »

Only the MiB wants to kill candidates. The only other reason you would want to kill a candidate is if they were also a wolf.
Messing with Jacob messes with the mythology of LOST
Any changes would be too messy. This game is perfectly balanced if the right player ends up as MiB
Logged
LogicallyLogical
FANDOM
Restaurant Master
*


You don't love me the same


View Profile
« Reply #3251 on: February 04, 2017, 04:41:17 PM »

Even before looking at this I can tell it's very long, complicated and gimmicky. After looking at it, I have to vote no.
Logged

I believe but not in you and me...
MariaYuki
Guest
« Reply #3252 on: February 04, 2017, 06:44:43 PM »

They spoiled Lost for me. Voting no.
Logged
saotome
Forum President
Restaurant Legend
*


bring on the tide


View Profile
« Reply #3253 on: February 04, 2017, 06:54:19 PM »

WAIT WhAT

THIS IS BASED OFF a SHOW?

i really hate bids based off of games, this makes sense now i should have read better
Logged

JEBZ Komics [Aug 30 11:30 PM]:    Brother E: We like them, just not the gay part
Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #3254 on: February 04, 2017, 07:43:22 PM »

They spoiled Lost for me. Voting no.
Lost ended a few years ago, spoilers are open game
I don't even see any spoilers here, aside from character names
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

Pages: 1 ... 215 216 [217] 218 219 ... 263   
Print
Jump to:  













Sorry, you must have JavaScript enabled to use the Flipline Forum.