Bidding Poll Topic

[! !22-22-7]

Self-heals are allowed (just didn't say it because I forgot to)

what should his win goal be? what is a good win goal?

investigation allows for him to claim seer which would make him op

[Kowhai]

investigation allows for him to claim seer which would make him op

1. The investigation wouldn't see colour or role, it would see whether or not his targets are candidates or not.
2. If he knows every role, he can already claim seer.

[! !22-22-7]

but he already finds out each candidate so its useless

[Kowhai]

Then either make it so that the investigative ability can check someone to see if they're Jacob, or just remove Jacob entirely.

[! !22-22-7]

none of the players are Jacob though

[Kowhai]

What is Jacob then?

[Nickito]

Make Jacob only available to perform actions on from Night 5 onwards

[! !22-22-7]

Then MiB will never win

Jacob is just a condition that needs to be met before MiB can optimize who to kill
if Jacob="alive"
then MiB="lose"

[Nickito]

joke

head

[! !22-22-7]

That was a terrible joke

[Abu]

joke

head

That's a rather small distance.

[Nickito]

Now that I think about it, that could actually work
Maybe not as late as Night 5, but like Night 3?

[Kowhai]

Jacob is just a condition that needs to be met before MiB can optimize who to kill
if Jacob="alive"
then MiB="lose"

And how is Jacob determined to be alive/dead?

[Nickito]

After Jacob is killed he is dead
Before Jacob is killed he is alive

[! !22-22-7]

It's an unwritten rule of TWG that night powers don't have to be used on someone who's still alive or in the game
it would just be a really terrible idea to do so

The difference is that in this game using a power on an otherwise non-entity actually makes sense