Bidding Poll Topic

[Abu]

I think I know who bid this one.

You probably do, just because of the theme anyways.

[Kowhai]

Humans are screwed.

[Abu]

I think people should somewhat have to explain their reasoning for both yes and no (would also help with preventing people just voting yes on everything).

It'd also help the bidders improve the game, if they want to re-send it and No option wins.

But also, people would need good reasoning and not more subjective one for example "I don't like the name of this role, so No".

[Kangablue]

I do feedback like that for every bid, unless its mine obviously.

[Abu]

I do feedback like that for every bid, unless its mine obviously.

Yep, I saw the feedback you had for this one.

[Nickito]

Invasion of the Ultra Beasts will not become a TWG (for now at least). Now onto the next bid

Role Swap:

TWG - Role Swap

TWG has had more than 60 successful games in the past, but one thing that this wannabe host has noticed is that in most games everyone's roles have never changed, and the few games that did have role changes were either known or unknown to change the original role list. This game, on the other hand, isn't like that. It starts out normal with each player only getting one role, but the problem is, there's another list that exists and no one really wants to think about how their role will change. Hence, the beginning of another werewolf game.

Role list -

Human
Human
Human
Insomniac
Mason

Seer
Cop
Guardian
Wolfsbane - except this Wolfsbane is immune to all attacks from anyone

Disguised Wolf
Wolf
Vicious Wolf - as long as this wolf is alive, they can kill twice per night. The other wolves don't know who the vicious wolf is but the vicious wolf knows the other wolves. The vicious wolf chooses their own victim without the wolves' knowing.

Maniac
Refugee
Vigilante
Vigilivanite - credits to Kangablue whose typos inspired this one. Like Vigilante but the main difference is that the vigilivanite can't win if the vigilante is dead, but the vigilante can win on his own. The vigilivanite knows the vigilante, but not the other way round.

If the vig's make it to the end, they have to keep shooting until they have majority. Also, each vig can shoot 3 times on whichever night they choose.

The catch: At the end of Day 2, all of the roles still alive (except the two vig's) will be given to a different player. Greens and blues are the only colours which can be switched (so reds will stay reds and blacks will stay black.) If the game reaches Day 4, the same process will occur again, except that there will be less roles to swap. There will only be two role swaps in the game.

[Ataino]

*cough Evolution cough*

[Cosmic]

The bidder stated there have been games like that though. This is different...

[Nickito]

Personally I vote no. 2 wolf kills, 2 vigilantes and a Cop is way too many night killing roles imo, and the role swaps would be annoying

[Chiral of Doom]

I voted Yes ONLY BECAUSE I would like to see this bid revised before the game begins. I like the concept, but...wolves are really OP.. Like, just get rid of the vicious wolf concept

[Abu]

Here's a random thing, I think that by default Wolfsbane should be protected from all attacks since that's being listed on nearly all of them.


This bid...I'll have to think about it a bit. Concept is great but I feel could be executed somewhat better, but I won't vote just yet.

[yves]

I voted Yes ONLY BECAUSE I would like to see this bid revised before the game begins. I like the concept, but...wolves are really OP.. Like, just get rid of the vicious wolf concept

that's purely the reason why i voted it, also I loved the Vigilivanite thing

[Abu]

Just saying if you think it should be revised you still should vote no I think...

[Kangablue]

Too many killing roles is one, and I dislike the whole Vig/Vilivanite combo, cause dosen't the Vigilivanite become pointless if the Vig dies?

And I have to dislike the changing roles as well, because if it was a set role you were becoming, or a few roles, that would be more realisitc, but doing it just any, even the same color means that theres a higher chance of random lynching and its even harder for the wolves to win. Wolves are actually UNDERPOWERED because of this, they could never kill blue roles cause they'll just be swapped.

Sorry, voted no, despite having a role based off of me.

[Oofis]

I'm going to take a little risk here and say that I'm the host. I know you're not meant to reveal but it was obvious enough already and, I'd like to say one thing about this bid, if it becomes a real game, I don't mind changing a few things before it starts.

Also

Too many killing roles is one, and I dislike the whole Vig/Vilivanite combo, cause dosen't the Vigilivanite become pointless if the Vig dies?

And I have to dislike the changing roles as well, because if it was a set role you were becoming, or a few roles, that would be more realisitc, but doing it just any, even the same color means that theres a higher chance of random lynching and its even harder for the wolves to win. Wolves are actually UNDERPOWERED because of this, they could never kill blue roles cause they'll just be swapped.

Sorry, voted no, despite having a role based off of me.

We know that the new roles are the same as the original roles, since it says in the bid. There shouldn't be too much random lynching in this.