Bidding Poll Topic

[PixelHunter]

- A little too much renaming, maybe make it closer to the actual role? (example: geeky human, rich human, etc.)
- People might get Light and Upgrade mixed up, I suggest having only one of the gimmicks to be in the game (and if it's Light, I'd suggest you have 2 Castle Guides)
- The fact that the humans have individual names makes it hard for the wolves to human claim. I'd suggest you give them individual names, sure, but make it so that the players who are human only know that they are human, and not know their traits.
- Town has no killing/guarding roles, and there are a lot of independent killers


Needs a lot of adjustments, so I'm voting no.

[Chiral of Doom]

So Nickito was describing a past TWG bid to me, where someone bidded a orange Mason, and it was the only orange colored role, and how the bidder failed the realize how problematic it was.
At that time, I was drinking water. I took a gulp of water, and laughed/breathed in at the same time, which resulted in the water going up my nose and me choking on it.
I laughed and then the water sprayed all over my touchscreen laptop. It almost broke the touchscreen but I was able to get all the water out my screen..but wow...
that was an experience.

[Abu]

Remember PepsiMan's TWG?

"You are the Mason"

[Nickito]

- The fact that the humans have individual names makes it hard for the wolves to human claim. I'd suggest you give them individual names, sure, but make it so that the players who are human only know that they are human, and not know their traits.

I'm pretty sure that the humans don't know what type of houseguest they are, or else the Mason would know that they're the Mason

[PixelHunter]

I'm pretty sure that the humans don't know what type of houseguest they are, or else the Mason would know that they're the Mason

Huh. Good point.

[Chiral of Doom]

Remember PepsiMan's TWG?

"You are the Mason"

LOL

[Shendelzare]

Don't worry, any found mistakes can be fixed once the bid is confirmed.

[Kowhai]

We're judging the bid on the poll, not potential alterations

[Nickito]

The Deathlock Castle by Adriel will be TWG LXXII!
Next bid, this one takes a different approach.

Cleansing and Peacefulness:

TWG - Cleansing and Peacefulness

Story: It was once said that the human and the wolf who doth leave the town shalt be cleansed, and then, there shall be peace all around. Well, the first part is true, as was shown when the humans and wolves all left the town and got cleansed, but there are still independents in town, and most of them are not at peace as of yet.

Rolelist:
Fool
Maniac
Amnesiac
Assassin - wins by making it to the end
Refugee
Refugee
Scientist
Student - can only get independent or cult roles
Arsonist - wins by killing everyone
Bounty Hunter
Monster
Blackmailer - wins if they are one of 5 or less people alive
Ghost - no ability, wins if they are visited by 3 or more people in one night
Protective Ghost - while this player is alive, the ghost can't be killed at night. Wins if the Ghost makes it to the end.
Cult Leader - wins by getting 50% or more cult population
Cultist

Gimmick: Well, it's clear to see what the gimmick is here. All the roles are independent, there are no green, blue or red roles. Victory conditions are normal unless stated. All roles win if they complete their goal before they die, even if they die after winning.

[Nickito]

I'm voting no for reasons I shouldn't have to say

[!!Vinny927]

Cult is terrible, auto-no everytime

[Leia]

Seems like a less-appealing less-balanced less-interesting version of Independence Day

Sorry but a no from me

[noname]

Nice concept, terrible execution

[Chiral of Doom]

Well....
there are just so many things wrong with this game mechanically...

[The Real Alien]

I believe I don't have to state why I voted no