Bidding Poll Topic

[Ataino]

does sun god win if all wolves die

I guess
you know how Vigi wins?
same with SG
"beats all if makes it to end"

[The Real Alien]

does sun god win if all wolves die

Yes, they are the same win conditions as Vigi

[Nickito]

Paranoia did not receive enough votes to become a TWG.
Did that bid not make you paranoid enough? Now it looks like the wolves could be in your own neighbourhood...

Neighborhood of fear:

Neighborhood of fear

A neighborhood of normal people were enjoying a nice simple life when one full moon, someone saw a werewolf roaming the streets!

Human
Human
Human
Lawyer human (When lynched, he does not die but a random person dies, then dies the next day)
Cosplay human (shows up as wolf in seer results but is human)
Seer
Vigilante
Arrogant person (Cannot gain any self-votes but instead votes a random person)
Blue human (A human that shows up to be blue)
Nurse (protects people)
Wolf
Lonely wolf (Dies on day 3 unless someone says the name of the wolf in the topic)
Cosplay wolf (disguised wolf)
Bomb wolf (Can kill one random person per game)

[The Real Alien]

I voted no because:
-Cosplay Human is Mason
-The Lawyer Human is actually a good idea if it doesn't die the next day
-Why is Vigilante blue?
-It will suck if the Arrogant Person is an inactive player
-What is the point of blue human? Just make it Gentleman or something
-Lonely Wolf is just a bad idea
-Why is Disguised Wolf red?
-What does "one random person per game" mean?

[Nickito]

-The colours here don't represent the Seer colours, but their factions (which is confusing)
-Vigilante is renamed Cop (I hope)
-Agree with Lenny's other points, plus the whole 4 wolves:10 humans ratio thing
-And only 14 sign ups is very small

[Oofis]

There are only 3 roles in this bid that are acceptable in a game. Human, Seer and Wolf. Everything else is either renamed, wrong colour, or downright pointless. For that, it's a no from me. Also, 13 is seriously not enough for a TWG.

[Lu]

Welcome Robin to the harsh world of TWG Bidding. Sorry, but it's a No.

A few reasons:
- Seer results are confusing because they represent factions not color (what Nickito said)
- Why would we want a blue mason?
- 4:10 Wolf to Human ratio
- Bomb Wolf is just 2 wolf kills in 1 night

[! !22-22-7]

Did anyone vote no solely because of the relatively small rolelist?

[Nickito]

That was one of my reasons, yes

[! !22-22-7]

So a perfectly good bid with a 14 person rolelist would receive a no vote from you?

[Nickito]

The standard number is 17-18
A rolelist of only 14 means that 3-4 people don't get to play

[Abu]

It shouldn't be your sole reasoning, but it can be a point to improve it.

[Nickito]

No it's a good reason to say no to a bid
We've got 6 bids waiting to be played, we need to start being very specific
Hosts are improving their bids, if we just say yes to every 6/10 bid, we won't get anywhere.
We should start accepting only 9/10's and 10/10's

[! !22-22-7]

The standard number is 17-18
A rolelist of only 14 means that 3-4 people don't get to play

If there were only 3 TWGs a year, this would be a valid concern.

[Abu]

There should be a min/max for bids anyways

16 minimum?