Bidding Poll Topic

[The Real Alien]

How does that win?

"Make it to the end" is vague

If all wolves die when Sun God is alive, they win
same if all humans die when Sun God is alive

[Nickito]

Independent roles count as a Human in the Human:Wolf ratio. The ratio can also be described as Wolves:Not Wolves

If the Human:Wolf ratio is even, and the Sun God/Vigilante/etc is still alive, then they win

[Chiral of Doom]

does sun god win if all wolves die

[Ataino]

does sun god win if all wolves die

I guess
you know how Vigi wins?
same with SG
"beats all if makes it to end"

[The Real Alien]

does sun god win if all wolves die

Yes, they are the same win conditions as Vigi

[Nickito]

Paranoia did not receive enough votes to become a TWG.
Did that bid not make you paranoid enough? Now it looks like the wolves could be in your own neighbourhood...

Neighborhood of fear:

Neighborhood of fear

A neighborhood of normal people were enjoying a nice simple life when one full moon, someone saw a werewolf roaming the streets!

Human
Human
Human
Lawyer human (When lynched, he does not die but a random person dies, then dies the next day)
Cosplay human (shows up as wolf in seer results but is human)
Seer
Vigilante
Arrogant person (Cannot gain any self-votes but instead votes a random person)
Blue human (A human that shows up to be blue)
Nurse (protects people)
Wolf
Lonely wolf (Dies on day 3 unless someone says the name of the wolf in the topic)
Cosplay wolf (disguised wolf)
Bomb wolf (Can kill one random person per game)

[Chiral of Doom]

i voted no
it's a bunch of

1.) renamed roles
2.) pointless roles
3.) i dont get why the cosplay human shows as wolf when it is green
4.) why is the disguised cosplay wolf red
5.) so the bomb wolf is essentially an extra wolf that can allow for 2 wolf kills in one night
6.) lack of roles

I think enough can be said for this game to be No

[The Real Alien]

I voted no because:
-Cosplay Human is Mason
-The Lawyer Human is actually a good idea if it doesn't die the next day
-Why is Vigilante blue?
-It will suck if the Arrogant Person is an inactive player
-What is the point of blue human? Just make it Gentleman or something
-Lonely Wolf is just a bad idea
-Why is Disguised Wolf red?
-What does "one random person per game" mean?

[Nickito]

-The colours here don't represent the Seer colours, but their factions (which is confusing)
-Vigilante is renamed Cop (I hope)
-Agree with Lenny's other points, plus the whole 4 wolves:10 humans ratio thing
-And only 14 sign ups is very small

[Oofis]

There are only 3 roles in this bid that are acceptable in a game. Human, Seer and Wolf. Everything else is either renamed, wrong colour, or downright pointless. For that, it's a no from me. Also, 13 is seriously not enough for a TWG.

[Leia]

Welcome Robin to the harsh world of TWG Bidding. Sorry, but it's a No.

A few reasons:
- Seer results are confusing because they represent factions not color (what Nickito said)
- Why would we want a blue mason?
- 4:10 Wolf to Human ratio
- Bomb Wolf is just 2 wolf kills in 1 night

[Chiral of Doom]

It's ok Robin
You were not the first
You won't be the last
Even the non amateurs like Spy Not have this happen to them

[!!Vinny927]

Did anyone vote no solely because of the relatively small rolelist?

[Nickito]

That was one of my reasons, yes

[!!Vinny927]

So a perfectly good bid with a 14 person rolelist would receive a no vote from you?