Poll
Question: Are players allowed to ban players from playing in the next game that they host?
Yes - 3 (15%)
No - 2 (10%)
In specific cases (see my post) - 15 (75%)
Other (explain) - 0 (0%)
Total Voters: 17

Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5] 6 7 ... 24   
Print
Author Topic: TWG Rules [Vote + explain in poll]  (Read 57585 times)
Kirby
Friend of Foodini
*


thonking intensifies


View Profile
« Reply #60 on: October 27, 2017, 02:21:43 AM »

/change
Allow dead and non players post ONLY if it is to clear up about  the game's role/gimmick (like alien/oxygen in space)
Logged

Faiz
Papa's Replacement
*****


View Profile
« Reply #61 on: October 27, 2017, 03:19:55 AM »

gonna change my vote.

/change

Increase the limit of postmortem posts to, say, 5 or 7.
Logged
Faiz
Papa's Replacement
*****


View Profile
« Reply #62 on: October 27, 2017, 06:16:41 AM »

Dead/Speculators can cluster up the topic, so if anyone can provide an analysis that they don't i'd change my vote
Logged
Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #63 on: October 27, 2017, 07:41:07 AM »

Yes it clutters the topic
I'm not trying to silence anyone, people can say stuff in the lounge
but the game topic is for the game
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

Kirby
Friend of Foodini
*


thonking intensifies


View Profile
« Reply #64 on: October 27, 2017, 07:42:17 AM »

Im also fine with anyone inside or outside the game to help host count votes
Logged

Lu
◢ ◤
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #65 on: October 27, 2017, 08:07:19 AM »

Can the next host reverse the ban? Because a) the ban was unfair and b) I want him to be able to play revolution
Talk to Nick, it's his decision. You could also just trade places in the queue with another host so that he can play.

/pass

Look, we have a lounge for a reason. The topic gets cluttered if it isn't. I'm not entirely sure why people are opposed to just posting in the lounge.
/change
Allow dead and non players post ONLY if it is to clear up about  the game's role/gimmick (like alien/oxygen in space)
I'm okay with this change but I don't see why this can't be posted in the Lounge
Logged

God Usopp [Aug 20 10:17 AM]:   costco is bestco

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fT9Q21sycyM
Bandero
Christian
Franchise Owner
*****


SUPER BOWL CHAMPS


View Profile
« Reply #66 on: October 27, 2017, 08:57:12 AM »

Dead players or spectators don't need to count votes. If they want to explain something about roles, they can do it in the lounge.
Logged

Long Signature:
TWG Stats:
LXXXIX - Win - Disguised Wolf
XC - Loss - Human
XCI - Loss - Insomniac
XCII - Win - Wolf
XCIII - Loss - Cheater
XCIV - Loss - Guardian
XCV - Game Died - Guardian
XCVI - Loss - Politician
XCVII - Loss - Seer
XCVIII - Loss - Human
XCIX - Win and MVP - Angakkuq
C - Loss - Wanderer
CI - Host
CII - Win - Insomniac
CIII - Loss - Disguised Wolf
CIV - Win - Human
CV - Loss - Human
CVI - Win - Arctic Wolf
CVII - Lose - Seer/Servant/Human
CVIII - Host
CIX - N/A
CX - Win - Lvov
CXI - Win and MVP - Arsonist
CXII - Win and MVP - Espionage Wolf
You are a true savage.
Makes name change poll
doesn't pick name with most votes
Kowhai
she/her
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #67 on: October 27, 2017, 03:23:21 PM »

If Lounges exist, the board gets cluttered.
If they don't, the topics get cluttered.
People can decide which they value more, but I personally get frustrated often when navigating old TWGs and sifting through games and lounges, often randomly jumbled up. Don't think things would be that confusing in topics, really.
Logged

TWG stats:
TWGXI - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXII - Brutal Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXIII - Coroner (Victory)
TWGXIV - Guardian (Victory)

TWGXV - Hunter (Loss)
TWGXVI - Fool (Loss)

TWGXVII - Seer (Loss, Human MVP)
TWGXIX - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXXI - Human (Loss)
TWGXXII - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXIII - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXIV - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXXVI - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXXVII - Human (Victory)
TWGXXVIII - Disguised Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)

TWGXXX - Mason (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXXII - Mason (Victory)

TWGXXXIII - Trapper (Loss)
TWGXXXIV - Human > Cultist (Victory)
TWGXXXV - Cop (Loss)
TWGXXXVI - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXXVIII - Transporter (Victory)
TWGXXXIX - Mercenary (Unfinished)

TWGXL - Riddler (Loss)
TWGXLI - Amnesiac (Loss)
TWGXLII - Vigilante (Loss, Independent MVP)

TWGXLIII - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXLV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXLVI - Maniac (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXLVII - Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXLVIII - Moderator (Loss)
TWGL - Gentleman > Cultist (Loss)
TWGLI - Wrathful Tenant (Victory)
TWGLII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLIV - Bounty Hunter (Loss)
TWGLVI - Pack Leader (Victory)
TWGLVII - Amnesiac > Necromancer (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLVIII - Seer (Loss)

TWGLIX - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLX - Warden (Victory)
TWGLXI - Student (Loss)
TWGLXII - Student > Hunter (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLXIII - Human > Fool (Loss)
TWGLXV - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXVI - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLXVII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLXVIII - Wolf (Victory)

TWGLXIX - Traitor (Victory, HM)
TWGLXX - Amnesiac > Seer (Loss)
TWGLXXI - Tinker (Victory, HM)
TWGLXXII - Seer (Victory, Overall MVP)

TWGLXXIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLXXIV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXV - Mason (Loss)
TWGLXXVI - Wolf (Loss)

TWGLXXVII - Sun God (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXVIII - Soldier (Loss)
TWGLXXIX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXX - Insomniac (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXI - Vigilante (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXII - Human (Loss)
TWGLXXXIII - Psycho (Loss)

TWGLXXXIV - Potion Maker (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXV - Priest (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXVI - Insomniac (Victory)
TWGLXXXVII - Necromancer (Loss)
TWGLXXXVIII - Clairvoyant (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXIX - Succubus (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXC - Wolf Shaman (Victory, Wolf MVP)
TWGXCI - Brutal Wolf (Loss)
TWGXCIII - Eidetic Wolf (Loss)

TWGXCIV - Disguised Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXCV - Hypnotizer (Unfinished)
TWGXCVI - Amnesiac > Kingsley (Loss)
TWGXCVII - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXCVIII - Amnesiac > Wolf Shaman (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGXCIX - Tide Chimer (Victory)
TWGC - Clairvoyant (Loss)
TWGCIII - Necromancer (Victory)
TWGCIV - Knot Expert (Victory)
TWGCVI - Snezhinka (Loss)
TWGCXVIII - Mason (Victory)
TWGCXIX - Coroner (Victory, Overall MVP)

Hosted:
TWGXVIII: Traitor!
TWGXXV: The Inhospitable Hospital
TWGXXXI: Colourblind
TWGXXXVII: Cold Blood
TWGXLIV: Independence Day
TWGXLIX: Deserted
TWGLV: Video Games
TWGLXIV: A Ghost Story
TWGXCII: Werewolves in SPACE!
TWGCVII: Age of Mythology
Kirby
Friend of Foodini
*


thonking intensifies


View Profile
« Reply #68 on: October 27, 2017, 03:37:13 PM »

except quoting is extremely hard to do if you wanna post it in a different topic of the quote and you are using a mobile Roll Eyes
plus in the game topic is more convenient
Logged

Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #69 on: October 27, 2017, 03:40:39 PM »

There are links to every game topic in the Stats topic, why would you ever search through the board
Also it wouldn't be messy if people just stopped bumping, we'd have an alternating lounge/game pattern
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

Kowhai
she/her
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #70 on: October 27, 2017, 03:47:11 PM »

People aren't going to stop bumping though?
Also, lounges aren't linked in Stats, as far as I know.
Logged

TWG stats:
TWGXI - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXII - Brutal Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXIII - Coroner (Victory)
TWGXIV - Guardian (Victory)

TWGXV - Hunter (Loss)
TWGXVI - Fool (Loss)

TWGXVII - Seer (Loss, Human MVP)
TWGXIX - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXXI - Human (Loss)
TWGXXII - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXIII - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXIV - Brutal Wolf (Loss, HM)
TWGXXVI - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXXVII - Human (Victory)
TWGXXVIII - Disguised Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)

TWGXXX - Mason (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXXXII - Mason (Victory)

TWGXXXIII - Trapper (Loss)
TWGXXXIV - Human > Cultist (Victory)
TWGXXXV - Cop (Loss)
TWGXXXVI - Guardian (Victory)
TWGXXXVIII - Transporter (Victory)
TWGXXXIX - Mercenary (Unfinished)

TWGXL - Riddler (Loss)
TWGXLI - Amnesiac (Loss)
TWGXLII - Vigilante (Loss, Independent MVP)

TWGXLIII - Guardian (Loss)
TWGXLV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGXLVI - Maniac (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXLVII - Wolf (Loss, Wolf MVP)
TWGXLVIII - Moderator (Loss)
TWGL - Gentleman > Cultist (Loss)
TWGLI - Wrathful Tenant (Victory)
TWGLII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLIV - Bounty Hunter (Loss)
TWGLVI - Pack Leader (Victory)
TWGLVII - Amnesiac > Necromancer (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLVIII - Seer (Loss)

TWGLIX - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLX - Warden (Victory)
TWGLXI - Student (Loss)
TWGLXII - Student > Hunter (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGLXIII - Human > Fool (Loss)
TWGLXV - Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXVI - Maniac (Loss)
TWGLXVII - Wolf (Loss)
TWGLXVIII - Wolf (Victory)

TWGLXIX - Traitor (Victory, HM)
TWGLXX - Amnesiac > Seer (Loss)
TWGLXXI - Tinker (Victory, HM)
TWGLXXII - Seer (Victory, Overall MVP)

TWGLXXIII - Human (Victory)
TWGLXXIV - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXV - Mason (Loss)
TWGLXXVI - Wolf (Loss)

TWGLXXVII - Sun God (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXVIII - Soldier (Loss)
TWGLXXIX - Vigilante (Loss)
TWGLXXX - Insomniac (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXI - Vigilante (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXII - Human (Loss)
TWGLXXXIII - Psycho (Loss)

TWGLXXXIV - Potion Maker (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXV - Priest (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGLXXXVI - Insomniac (Victory)
TWGLXXXVII - Necromancer (Loss)
TWGLXXXVIII - Clairvoyant (Loss, HM)
TWGLXXXIX - Succubus (Victory, Independent MVP)

TWGXC - Wolf Shaman (Victory, Wolf MVP)
TWGXCI - Brutal Wolf (Loss)
TWGXCIII - Eidetic Wolf (Loss)

TWGXCIV - Disguised Wolf (Victory, Overall MVP)
TWGXCV - Hypnotizer (Unfinished)
TWGXCVI - Amnesiac > Kingsley (Loss)
TWGXCVII - Human (Unfinished)
TWGXCVIII - Amnesiac > Wolf Shaman (Victory, Independent MVP)
TWGXCIX - Tide Chimer (Victory)
TWGC - Clairvoyant (Loss)
TWGCIII - Necromancer (Victory)
TWGCIV - Knot Expert (Victory)
TWGCVI - Snezhinka (Loss)
TWGCXVIII - Mason (Victory)
TWGCXIX - Coroner (Victory, Overall MVP)

Hosted:
TWGXVIII: Traitor!
TWGXXV: The Inhospitable Hospital
TWGXXXI: Colourblind
TWGXXXVII: Cold Blood
TWGXLIV: Independence Day
TWGXLIX: Deserted
TWGLV: Video Games
TWGLXIV: A Ghost Story
TWGXCII: Werewolves in SPACE!
TWGCVII: Age of Mythology
Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #71 on: October 27, 2017, 05:41:12 PM »

There should be a link to the lounge (if it exists) and the game topic
Then there's no reason to be upset about clutter in the board
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

Nickito
/r/flipline Moderator
Food Critic
*


Visit /r/flipline!


View Profile
« Reply #72 on: October 27, 2017, 07:57:17 PM »

So are you planning on linking games and lounges?
I think it's a good idea, although it will be time consuming
Logged

AskJoe [Oct 06 12:17 AM]:   Okay, so maybe I was wrong all along and God actually does exist.

Join the Phoenix ORG Discord server! https://discord.gg/XSTP4Tz

Lu
◢ ◤
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #73 on: October 29, 2017, 07:53:00 AM »

Rule #1 Voting Results

Do not post in the game thread if you are dead. You may make one post after you die, but after that you are not allowed to post. Breaking this rule will result in 1 gameban.

/pass: 5 votes
- Nickito
- greenviceroy
- Daenerys
- Archi
- Lu

/change: 2 votes
- Kassem: Allow dead and non players post ONLY if it is to clear up about  the game's role/gimmick (like alien/oxygen in space)
- Coach Huzzy: Increase the limit of postmortem posts to, say, 5 or 7.

/reject: 3 votes
- KrispyKremeExtreme: Posting in the topic should not be a big deal as long as it doesn't reveal any important game info. Plus, we don't want to be too harsh on gamebans/modkills since it's usually a last resort thing like if the player is genuinely a problem, rude, gamethrowing
- Qazikol: I don't get why those functions aren't part of the main topic. Besides, we've already got rules for staying dead, don't see why extra rules restricting where people can be dead are necessary.
- Lusamine: As long as nobody discusses the game it doesn’t really change anything.

This rule has been passed. It is now in effect and applies to all games starting now.
Logged

God Usopp [Aug 20 10:17 AM]:   costco is bestco

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fT9Q21sycyM
Lu
◢ ◤
Restaurant Master
*



View Profile
« Reply #74 on: October 29, 2017, 07:59:14 AM »

Next proposed rule (if anyone was curious, I'm currently just going down the list of rules in the HQ to start out with so we can edit those first before we add new ones)

Do not delete/edit posts. You can edit typos, but you should not edit otherwise. If you change your mind about something, too bad. This can interfere with other people's strategies. The first time you edit a post will result in a warning, but the second time you edit a post will result in a modkill.
Logged

God Usopp [Aug 20 10:17 AM]:   costco is bestco

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fT9Q21sycyM
Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5] 6 7 ... 24   
Print
Jump to:  













Sorry, you must have JavaScript enabled to use the Flipline Forum.