CristinaKief: You look like a farmer's wife here which I can't criticize really. I like the colour scheme, it's okay, maybe a touch of bright colour?.The clothes give farmer vibes. Pretty much the same to everyone else, it's a bit cold so maybe a bigger jacket. A nice job.
8/10Enigma: The colour scheme contains a lot of desaturated grayish colours, making the outfit look quite old, which I guess is what you were going for since you made a historical outfit. It looks very, very nice, might I add. Plenty of detail, an original idea and a really fitting colour scheme, but most importantly, everything, down to the tiniest accessories, fits in perfectly with the theme of the outfit.
9/10Owen: Hey, Cristina, I like your outfit since it has a lot of detail within it and each of your accessories is perfect in your outfit. Your colour schemes and choice of clothing is great and you've done amazingly!
9/10April: Your outfit looks great, and the colors work very well together. The shirt, jacket, and skirt go very well together. However, I would have liked to see more traditional Irish colors, since this outfit doesn’t seem too Irish. You get an
8/10DrakeKief: It's okay. It's pretty plain and simple. The hat, the overalls, I suppose it's good. It's pretty boring but it's not awful. Meh.
6/10Enigma: Okay, I can see how you've ended up with this design. The problem I have with this round's scores is that nearly everyone has pretty much the same outfit, so there's not much I can base my scores on without giving everyone the same exact score. You've used a three-colour scheme here, but that's actually okay because the colours complement each other so well. There's enough detail as well. All in all, a decent outfit.
8/10Owen: Hey, Drake, your outfit is definitely giving me those Irish farmer vibes but it possibly could be just a bit simple. What I can see from here, your colour scheme is not creative at all. You used black, white and green, that is certainly a bland colour choice and I'm wishing for a more appropriate one.
7/10April: Your outfit definitely gives me the impression of the farmer. The hat, overalls, gloves, and heavy-duty shoes are all perfect fits for a farmer, so you did a really good job with that. Your striped shirt also adds good detail to the rest of the outfit. You get a
9/10LenaKief: Oh dear. I'm sorry, but I'm lost. You're work isn't explained, so I'm left to guess. The barely a colour scheme is bad, none of this really says farmer and it's simple. It's a poor attempt... Where you've gained a point to me is actually the hair change. Wow.
2/10Enigma: It's. So. Yellow. You've actually used a two-colour scheme here, which is already bad, but the second color is hardly even used, meaning you've basically got a one-colour scheme here! On an outfit that's so simple, it can be construed to mean anything from a sunflower to a lumberjack! Come on, it's like you're not even trying!
2/10Owen: Hi, Lena, I mean, what's gone on with your outfit? Yellow? The clothing choice and colour scheme is so poor and lacks of creativity and skill which is something you definitely need in the FC Games. I'll keep this short and sweet but here's one thing: you need to improve.
3/10April: The only part of the outfit that seems like a farmer to me is the gloves. Nothing in the outfit seems Irish to me, either. I think you should have done a lot more. You get a
3/10CelestineKief: I don't know if it's me, but I don't really get it. I do think farmers are different around the world. An Irish Farmer is different to a Kenyan, Texan, Asian, anything. Anyway, onto the design, it makes sense from your explanation but I'm not totally sold on the design. I'm a bit confused. I see more of an artist here than farmer. It's okay, just not special to me.
7/10Enigma: It's a good thing you told me that not being Irish was a statement, because, and I quote, "A farmer is a farmer, no matter where they're from." I totally agree! And this is just perfect! The colour scheme is nicely balanced, there's enough detail to go around, and the outfit as a whole looks about as farmer-like as you can get. The idea to use darkened colours on the shoes to simulate dirt was genius! Amazing job!
10/10Owen: Greetings, Celestine! Okay, your outfit's colours are nicely balanced and the outfit obviously has those farmer vibes which is a positive comment. I wish the colours seemed more farmer-like but your design is great and you followed the brief so here's your
8/10April: You meet the farmer criteria fairly well. However, I’m not sensing much related to Ireland. Although you did use green and orange, it’s overwhelmed by the navy blue overalls and pants. Also, the shirt seems like Christmas. You get a
7/10TannerKief: Again, basic style and theme here. The colour scheme really saves the design and gives it it's points to me. The green hints work well with the brown and orange and the shoelace. Pretty basic but a lot more detailed than others.
9/10Enigma: A rich and varied colour scheme, a highly coordinated and detailed outfit, AND a perfect fit with the objective? Tanner, this is the second time in a row you've made an outfit warranting a perfect score from multiple judges! How are you this good?
10/10Owen: Woah! Tanner, the outfit looks great! Ireland vibes, farmer vibes and this is all I've ever asked for! Wow, I love this outfit! Just amazing job, Tanner, you're certainly going to be a strong contender.
10/10April: You did a good job balancing the colors here. You added the traditional white, orange, and green, but you also balanced it out with the shades of brown. The cap and gloves are also good choices. However, I don’t really like the way the colors are organized in the shoes. It feels a bit off to me. You get an
8/10FleurKief: Yes, I do like this. The design makes sense, looks farmery, great colours, great clothes, great style. Where I say this is Irishy is by the actual clothes. The bodywarmer on sweater and the hat. It works. It is pretty standard but done better than the majority of submissions. Great work!
9/10Enigma: Wow. That is a really dark colour scheme. Dark red on black with wine red and dark brown. It's almost dark enough to hide the fact that this outfit hardly looks anything like a farmer, let alone an Irish one. If you're going for a historical outfit, don't wear a modern puffy vest! And for flip's sake, use some lighter colours!
5/10Owen: Greetings to you, Fleur! To kick things off, your colour scheme is extremely dark and does not represent Ireland whatsoever. Your design is certainly farmer-like but the colour scheme is a fatal flaw. I know it's your colour scheme you tried to implement but it would've been better to insert more Irish colours to get a better score.
7/10April: Although your outfit does look nice, I am a bit confused about your choice of colors here. The striped shirt seems to clash with the rest of the outfit. Also, I don’t quite see how this would be considered Irish. A reference image would have been nice. You get a
6/10NadineKief: Simple, sweet, nice. Farmer vibes are slightly there, the design is nice. It is pretty basic and key word, jacket. Anyway, it's okay. You're on the right track here. I hope this is enough for you.
8/10Enigma: You're actually suffering from the opposite problem that a lot of the others have. Plenty of Irish, not enough farmer. Don't get me wrong, your outfit looks fine. A really simple colour scheme, but plenty of detail that's appropriately Irish. However, you should really have made it more of a farmer. It's probably also a good idea to use more than two main colours. The brown is present, but doesn't stand out enough.
7/10Owen: Pleasure seeing you again, Nadine! Your design gives me Irish vibes but not that much farmer vibes. I think with a few tweaks with the colours, adding a jacket and implementing more farmer-like accessories, your outfit could be amazing. Some negatives and some positives so here's your score which is
7/10April: You did a good job incorporating both Irish colors and symbols into your outfit. I like the cap and shoes that you chose, since those are typical farmer clothing items. The black and white skirt was also a nice choice on your part. You get a
9/10CindyI'm afraid you were too late submitting and really minimised your chances of being judged by only sending it to me, particularly when most had already judged.
AnthonyKief: I don't know how to critique this. I don't get it. What is a "modern" farmer over a "stereotypical" one? Why is he wearing shades? When was yellow an Irish colours? I don't really understand this design much. You should've explained it more because I'm totally lost.
4/10Enigma: I wish I could actually give this a good score. The colours, the details, everything looks good. However, since you so blatantly ignored the prompt, I'm forced to reduce your score drastically. 5/10 is the best I can do.
5/10Owen: Hello there, Anthony. In this outfit, I can see some negatives and some positives. The positives are that your design is great and your colour scheme is great and could be finished off with some tweaks. The negatives are that you kind of ignored the brief and it does not look like an Irish farmer at all. If this wasn't about an Irish farmer, you'd be getting a good score, but it's the complete opposite of that.
6/10April: You definitely got the Irish colors down, so good job. I do think you should have added some darker colors in order to balance the bright orange, green, and yellow. Also, this outfit doesn’t seem much like a farmer to me. The gloves, pants, and shoes are good, but I don’t really understand much else, like the hat. You get a
6/10LeilaKief: I think it's a nice design, and it is an animal carer type farmer which I appreciate. You've missed out the key part "Irish". This is a Ruler challenge, remember. As far as detail on the design goes it's great. I like it, truth be told.
7/10Enigma: I thought you needed to always wear a hijab? Or does your faith suddenly allow other headwear, too? Regardless, this outfit is actually not that good. The design is very simplistic, which makes for a gaping lack of detail. The colours are mostly very pale pastel tints, and the little bit of brown doesn't make up for it. You almost look more like a nurse than a farmer, and Ireland doesn't come into the equation at all.
6/10Owen: Nice to see you again, Leila. Now, like Anthony, you tried to avoid the stereotypical farmer design and frankly, your design is decent but the colors you have chosen are not great. Most of them are in the pastel palette which means they are quite light in colour and you've used that mostly with your design so that's a bit unfortunate. Like I previously mentioned, the design is decent but it doesn't look like that much of a farmer.
5/10April: This outfit definitely meets the farmer criteria, meaning that you made good clothing choices. The overalls, gloves, and shoes are very good choices. However, I would have liked to see some traditional Irish colors, because this outfit seems more like a typical farmer rather than an Irish farmer. You get a
7/10ColinKief: Again, one of the better basic designs we have. Pretty simple with the theme, nice design, nice colours, makes sense but this is Ireland so take care with the clothing choices.
8/10Enigma: This outfit is good. The colour scheme is well balanced, the detail is in place and the outfit looks the way it's supposed to, like a farmer. There's not much Ireland in it besides the green, but I think that might just be enough here.
8/10Owen: Hi, Colin, like Lucy, you just look like a farmer and not a Irish farmer, the outfit seems a bit too safe but it still looks like a farmer. It's nothing bad, but you just didn't completely fit the brief since you inserted no part of Ireland whatsoever.
6/10April: I like how you used the purple, blue, and gray on the shirt. It goes well with the brown and green that is seen on the rest of his outfit. It’s also nice that you included Irish colors but didn’t overdo it. Overall, I like your outfit, and I can’t really find much to critique. You get a
9/10JoeyKief: Hehehe, I really like this. It makes sense, gives off slight farmer vibes with belt, jeans and boots. Thank goodness you have used a jacket here, I think that's really clever. The gloves should be a different colour though I think.
8/10Enigma: I appreciate the effort, but you've kind of missed the mark on this one, Joey. You were clearly trying to get across a 'farmer' impression, but the end result looks more like someone you'd meet in the tropics than in Ireland. I think it's the hat. That hat, especially when combined with that colour of coat, gives off a distinct tropics impression.
7/10Owen: Pleasure seeing you again, Joey, your color scheme is very unique and has been used well onto your outfit but maybe you could add more Ireland vibes somehow and maybe change the hat. Wink It's a nice effort, Joey.
7/10April: I like the hat and shoes you wore, since they are something that would typically be found on a farmer. The green gloves and shirt also add a nice Irish touch. However, I do think that you should have made the color scheme simpler. I feel like there’s too much going on here. You get a
7/10
Tanner: 37
Jenny: 34
Cristina: 34
Azaleah: 33
Amber: 33
Chayce: 32
Celestine: 32
Destiny: 31
Nadine: 31
Colin: 31
Andrew: 30
Drake: 30
Joey: 29
Lucy: 27
Fleur: 27
Leila: 25
Liam: 24
Bethany: 21
Anthony: 21
Xania: 11
Lena: 10
Ariana: 9
Cindy: 0
Tanner: 37
Chayce: 32
Celestine: 32
Colin: 31
See you soon for the next challenge!