SierraEnigma: First off, I want to say that a minstrel was a creative choice. It certainly makes for an interesting outfit, and it lets you pull off things that would otherwise earn you a bad score from me, like having a mismatched over-vibrant colour scheme. It actually works quite well, all things considered.
8.5/10April: A minstrel is a great idea, and it’s definitely one of the more creative ideas of the bunch. Every clothing item here is well thought out, and I can tell that you did your research. One thing that could be improved, however, is the color scheme. I'm not really feeling the red-green-blue combination, and the random gold on the ring and brown feather on the hat seem out of place. You get a
7/10.
Tanner: A minstrel is a creative way to interpret this challenge! I like how you put thought into every piece of clothing from this outfit; my personal favorites are the backpack for holding the instruments, and ring given to her by the royal family she works for. I think a different shirt could have been used however. It has a high collar like you said minstrels have, but I don’t think it matches the look you were going for. As for the color scheme… well, while I like that you acknowledged minstrel’s clothing to be colorful and random, I think you went about that idea in the wrong way here. Red, green, blue, purple, white, black, and brown are all seven completely different colors, and it’s not easy to combine them all together into one functional color scheme. My suggestion would be to use less of different colors, and more of different shades, such as light and dark blue for example.
6.5/10Spencer: I really like the minstrel idea, but to be honest, it’s a bit of a mess when made into an outfit. I think there are two main issues here, the random looking outfit, and the color scheme. Now I know the outfit isn’t random, since you gave a bunch of explanation on every clothing item, but they just don’t look good together. The color scheme just clashes and doesn’t work. I’m sorry,
6/10AaronEnigma: Well, I certainly did not expect Link to show up in this challenge, but I have to say, I really like it! The colour scheme, the detail, the jacket, everything looks great!
9/10April: Usually when you see those two bright blues, you see them in a Summer Luau outfit, so I'm glad that they're being used elsewhere. They go so well with the different shades of brown, which makes for an awesome color scheme. I also enjoyed how you took inspiration from Link, especially with the elf ears. Nice job, Aaron! You get a
9/10.
Tanner: How. Like. How even. I wasn’t expecting to see an elf for this challenge, but Aaron, you rocked this challenge! Everything looks just amazing here: the color scheme has great balance in it and it’s pleasing to the eye, and I really like how you went about choosing medieval-looking royal clothing like the BavariaFest shirt and the jacket. Every part of this outfit looks great on you, and I am super impressed with this one. Kudos to you, Aaron! You never cease to amaze me.
10/10Spencer: I absolutely love this outfit. Also Synth, the fact that you called Link an elf, offends me. Anywayyy, I love how you were inspired by Link from BoTW, and I love how you made a Hylian Prince outfit! The color scheme is wonderful and I love the outfit, wonderful job!
10/10JuanEnigma: This is really good. Nice colour scheme, plenty of detail, and an interesting theme. I really see the Disney prince in this outfit. Well done.
9/10April: I can definitely see how this outfit was inspired by Disney princes (I keep wanting to say princess Laugh), especially because of the color scheme. It seems so fitting for a Disney character. The clothing choices are good and make sense, and it's a solid outfit overall. There's nothing much to critique here, as everything fits in and looks great. You get a
9/10.
Tanner: I like your idea behind this one! You can definitely see the Snow White inspiration here and overall I think you captured the classic prince look very well. One small detail I have to applaud you on is how you colored the ring; usually rings have weird color choices, but gold and red look very natural here, great job with that! However, I’m not so sure I like the pants being plain white, and the coloring of the jacket seems a little strange to me (not the vest, just the brown parts and the squiggly lines).
9/10Spencer: First, I really like the color scheme, it’s really nice, but I would’ve liked red somewhere else but it is a lot of red in one spot so it’s understandable using it only there. Now I love the Disney inspiration, and it’s clear as day too, very nicely done.
9/10CoraEnigma: I don't know why exactly I like this one so much, but I do. There's lots of detail, a great colour scheme and it looks positively regal. There's some items that have no right to suit the outfit as well as they do. Who knew queens looked so good in turtleneck sweaters?
9.5/10April: This color scheme is really eye-appealing and pleasant to look at. I love it. Every clothing item looks fancy, royal, and fit for a king...wait, queen, sorry. I’m also liking all the gold details, and they’re a good way to complement the gold crown. Now, I would have liked an explanation, since all you did was list the clothing items and colors you chose. Remember, we can see that already - we want to know the "why," not the "what." You get a
6.5/10.
Tanner: We’ve already covered that listing your clothing items and colors don’t count as an explanation, so I’ll be taking 1.5 points from your score. This one’s interesting to me, because I can see the queen aspect of this outfit, but at the same time, it also doesn’t feel like one, if that makes sense. Sure, the crown is there, and the royal cape is there, but other than that, I can’t see a queen wearing any of this. I really don’t like the turtleneck, and although the jacket is fancy, it just doesn’t feel right to me. The color choices aren’t my favorite either. Gold, orange, and dark green is a promising start, but the brown and grey don’t feel right here at all.
5.5/10Spencer: This is a very unique color scheme for a queen outfit, I like it! But you didn’t explain anything, I want to know why you chose such interesting colors. The outfit itself doesn’t need much explanation, it’s a queen outfit, duh. Not sure about the skirt though. I’d give you a 9 but you earned a penalty so you’ll get a
7.5/10MercedesEnigma: I know I always tell people off for using too many vibrant colours, but a jester outfit is one of the few times where I actually expect them. With this colour scheme, your outfit looks kind of dampened and toned down, while jesters are all about bright colours and standing out. That being said, though, it's still a great outfit, and deserves a high score.
9/10April: This outfit is fantastic! I love the color scheme, and you did a great job making an outfit that's both realistic and jester-like. You used clothing items that aren't seen often at all, such as the hat and shoes, and I appreciate that. If there was only one thing to critique, it would be the fact that the pants are striped. In my opinion, making the pants plain (the more purple color, not the blue) would have been a good idea. However, that's just a tiny detail in a great outfit overall. You get a
9/10.
Tanner: The second I saw this outfit, I knew it was going to get a perfect score. It’s super innovative, you made great use of some of the more unused items in PLP, and you made them look good together? Come. ON! This outfit feels like a modernized version of a jester because of the vest and tie, but that makes the outfit so much better in my eyes because you took a great risk that worked so well in the long run. Wonderful job with this outfit, Mercedes!
10/10Spencer: I love the jester idea! And you pulled it off wonderfully! I absolutely love the color scheme, I like how you decided not to use the color schemes from your reference images because you knew they wouldn’t work well in an outfit, very smart Mercedes! The clothing items are absolutely perfect and she genuinely looks like a jester. I’m extremely impressed Mercedes, the idea, the execution, all perfect!
10/10LavenderEnigma: Um... the vampire challenge was the other Transsylvania one, but the outfit itself actually looks rather good. You called it your worst outfit so far, but it's actually not that bad. The thing I dislike most is the green bits, I think. It just doesn't suit the colour scheme that well.
8.5/10April: I love how that skirt looks here. It's such a pleasant color and it just fits in so well, especially with the jacket. I can't say the same about the shirt though. It doesn't look bad, but I think there were other options that would have fit in better here. The rest of the outfit is pretty good, so I hope that eases your worrying a bit. You get an
8/10.
Tanner: I can definitely understand why you feel unsure about this one, because it’s so different from your other outfits. However, I do like the direction you went in for this outfit because the mystical-looking colors blend rather well with the fancy conductor look you were trying to go for. You have a unique choice of colors that I’ve never seen done before. It works quite well, but I’m not sure if I like the dress and the shirt having the same color, or your choice of shirt either. I like the idea of having that cape here, although I think the stars and moons could have been a lighter shade since they blend in weird with the cape’s main color. Overall I think this outfit feels incomplete, but it has a lot of potential for improvement.
7.5/10Spencer: Oh I like this. The colors are really nice. I love the look of the dress. I also love how it looks like a vampire outfit, but not a traditional vampire outfit, it’s difficult to explain really. Anyway the cape is also very nice and the glasses are cool.
8.5/10SamEnigma: Okay, this is amazing. You pulled off a great medieval armor look while using none of the standard knight parts. The vest, the Roman helmet, everything just fits so well together. Great job!
9.5/10April: I don't think I've ever seen that hat used in the FC Games (although I could be wrong), so it's good to see you using it. It works perfectly here, as do most of the clothing items. This is a great representation of a guard! You get an
8.5/10.Tanner: We barely ever get to see that gladiator hat used, but it looks really cool here! I appreciate that you didn’t take the easy way out by dressing in all grey knight clothing, but instead, you improved on that idea by adding your own touches, just like you did with your very successful mime outfit in the ICWs. The muscle shirt looks really great here, as does the arrow quiver. Really the only thing I don’t like about this one is the pirate belt since I feel like there could have been a better option, but I still love this outfit to pieces. Well done!
9.5/10Spencer: This is a very unique outfit, I really like it! First I never thought I’d like an outfit with that shirt but you proved me wrong, I seriously hate that shirt but it works here. The helmet and arrows usually don’t fit in an outfit but they’re perfect here, and the belt looks really cool. Nicely done.
9/10